Which problems does digital identity have?

Continuation from post SSI: Digital Identity User Experience

Digital identity systems have evolved rapidly over the past few decades, but they've also created a host of new problems. Understanding these problems is crucial for designing better solutions and avoiding the mistakes of the past.

After working in this space for a while, I've seen these problems firsthand. They're not just theoretical issues, they're real problems that affect millions of people every day. And the scary part is, most people don't even realize how broken the current system is until something goes wrong.

The Fragmentation Problem

Multiple Identities

Most people today have dozens of different digital identities, one for each service they use. This creates several problems:

• Password fatigue: Users have to remember multiple passwords, leading to weak passwords and security risks
• Inconsistent experiences: Each service has its own login process, making the user experience confusing
• Data silos: Information is trapped in different systems, making it difficult to get a complete picture of a user

I know I have this problem. I have accounts on probably 50+ different services, and I can't even remember half of them. Every time I want to use a new app, I have to create another account, remember another password, and go through another verification process. It's exhausting, and it's not sustainable.

The Social Login Dependency

While social login (Google, Facebook, Apple) has made things easier, it has also created new problems:

• Single points of failure: If your Google account is compromised, you lose access to multiple services
• Platform lock-in: Users become dependent on specific platforms for their digital identity
• Privacy concerns: These platforms collect vast amounts of data about user behavior

This is the trap we've all fallen into. Social login seemed like a great solution at first, one click and you're logged in everywhere. But now we're completely dependent on these companies. If Google decides to lock you out, you lose access to dozens of services. If Facebook changes their policies, you're stuck. We've traded convenience for control, and now we're paying the price.

The Security Problem

Data Breaches

Digital identity systems are constantly under attack, and data breaches have become commonplace:

• Personal information exposure: When systems are breached, personal data is exposed
• Identity theft: Stolen identity information can be used to impersonate users
• Financial fraud: Compromised identities can lead to financial losses

Data breaches have become so common that we've almost become numb to them. Every few months, there's another major breach affecting millions of people. Equifax, Yahoo, Facebook, LinkedIn, the list goes on and on. And the worst part is, there's often nothing you can do about it. Your data is out there, and it's not coming back.

Weak Authentication

Many digital identity systems still rely on weak authentication methods:

• Password-based systems: Passwords are inherently insecure and difficult to manage
• Single-factor authentication: Many systems don't use additional security measures
• Social engineering: Users are often tricked into revealing their credentials

The password system is fundamentally broken. We're asking people to create unique, complex passwords for dozens of different services, and then remember them all. It's impossible. So people either use weak passwords, reuse passwords across services, or write them down somewhere. All of these create security vulnerabilities. And even when companies try to help with 2FA, it just adds more friction to an already broken system.

The Privacy Problem

Data Collection

Digital identity systems collect vast amounts of personal data:

• Behavioral tracking: Every action is recorded and analyzed
• Cross-platform tracking: Data is shared between different services
• Surveillance: Users are constantly monitored and profiled

This is the part that really creeps me out. Every click, every scroll, every second you spend on a page is being tracked and analyzed. Companies know more about your behavior than you do. They know when you're most likely to buy something, what makes you angry, what makes you happy. And they're using this information to manipulate you. It's not just about showing you relevant ads, it's about controlling your behavior.

Lack of Control

Users have little control over their data:

• Terms of service: Complex legal documents that users don't understand
• Data portability: Difficult to move data from one service to another
• Data deletion: Hard to completely remove data from systems

The terms of service problem is particularly frustrating. These documents are written by lawyers, for lawyers. They're intentionally complex and confusing. Most people just click "agree" without reading them, which is exactly what companies want. And even if you do read them, you often don't have a choice, it's either agree to the terms or don't use the service. That's not really a choice.

The Usability Problem

Complex Interfaces

Many digital identity systems are difficult to use:

• Confusing flows: Users don't understand what's happening during authentication
• Technical jargon: Systems use terminology that users don't understand
• Multiple steps: Authentication processes are often too complex

I've seen this firsthand. Users get confused by authentication flows all the time. They don't understand why they need to verify their email, why they need to set up 2FA, or why they need to answer security questions. The whole process feels like a maze, and users just want to get to the service they're trying to use. The authentication process should be invisible, not a barrier.

Inconsistent Experiences

Different services handle identity differently:

• Different requirements: Each service has its own rules and requirements
• Different interfaces: No consistent design patterns across services
• Different security measures: Inconsistent security practices

This inconsistency is maddening. One service wants your phone number, another wants your address, another wants your social security number. One service uses SMS for 2FA, another uses an authenticator app, another uses email. There's no rhyme or reason to it. Users have to learn a different system for every service they use, which creates confusion and frustration.

The Trust Problem

Lack of Transparency

Users don't understand how their data is being used:

• Hidden data collection: Users don't know what data is being collected
• Complex privacy policies: Legal documents are too complex to understand
• Unclear data sharing: Users don't know who has access to their data

This is the trust problem in a nutshell. Users are expected to trust companies with their most personal information, but these companies don't trust users enough to be transparent about what they're doing with that information. It's a one-way street, and users are getting the short end of the stick.

Institutional Dependencies

Users are dependent on institutions they don't trust:

• Government surveillance: Concerns about government access to personal data
• Corporate control: Large tech companies have too much power over digital identity
• Lack of accountability: No clear accountability when things go wrong

This is the fundamental problem. We're all dependent on institutions that we don't trust, and we have no choice in the matter. You can't opt out of having a digital identity in today's world. You can't opt out of government surveillance. You can't opt out of corporate data collection. You're forced to participate in a system that you don't control and don't trust.

The Accessibility Problem

Digital Divide

Not everyone has equal access to digital identity systems:

• Technology barriers: Some people don't have access to necessary technology
• Literacy barriers: Some people don't have the skills to use digital systems
• Economic barriers: Some people can't afford the necessary devices or services

This is something that often gets overlooked. We assume everyone has a smartphone, everyone has internet access, everyone knows how to use digital systems. But that's not true. There are millions of people who are excluded from the digital world because they don't have the right technology, the right skills, or the right resources. And as more services move online, these people are being left behind.

Exclusion

Digital identity systems can exclude certain groups:

• Documentation requirements: Some people don't have the required documents
• Biometric systems: Some people can't use biometric authentication
• Language barriers: Systems may not be available in all languages

This is a huge problem that doesn't get enough attention. If you're a refugee, you might not have the documents required to create a digital identity. If you have a disability, you might not be able to use biometric authentication. If you don't speak English, you might not be able to understand the interface. These systems are designed for the privileged few, not for everyone.

The Scalability Problem

Centralized Systems

Most digital identity systems are centralized, which creates problems:

• Single points of failure: If the central system goes down, everything stops
• Bottlenecks: Centralized systems can become overloaded
• Vulnerability: Centralized systems are attractive targets for attackers

Centralized systems are a disaster waiting to happen. If Google's servers go down, millions of people lose access to their accounts. If a government database gets hacked, millions of people's identity data gets compromised. We've put all our eggs in one basket, and that basket is made of glass.

Interoperability Issues

Different systems don't work well together:

• Competing standards: Different organizations use different standards
• Data format differences: Data is stored in incompatible formats
• Integration challenges: It's difficult to connect different systems

This is the interoperability nightmare. Every company has their own way of doing things, their own standards, their own data formats. It's like trying to get people who speak different languages to work together without a translator. The result is a fragmented mess where nothing works together.

The Future Problem

Legacy Systems

Existing systems are difficult to change:

• Technical debt: Old systems are built on outdated technology
• Institutional inertia: Organizations are resistant to change
• Cost of migration: It's expensive to upgrade existing systems

This is the legacy problem. We're stuck with systems that were built decades ago, using technology that's completely outdated. But changing them is expensive, risky, and time-consuming. So we keep patching them up, adding more layers of complexity, making them even harder to change. It's a vicious cycle.

The Path Forward

Understanding these problems is the first step toward solving them. The next generation of digital identity systems needs to address:

1. Fragmentation: Create unified, interoperable identity systems
2. Security: Implement strong, user-friendly authentication methods
3. Privacy: Give users control over their data and make data practices transparent
4. Usability: Design simple, consistent user experiences
5. Trust: Build systems that users can understand and trust
6. Accessibility: Ensure that digital identity systems work for everyone
7. Scalability: Design systems that can grow and adapt to new challenges

The problems with current digital identity systems are significant, but they're not insurmountable. With the right approach and technology, we can build better systems that serve users' needs while protecting their privacy and security.

I know this sounds like a lot, and it is. But I believe it's possible. We have the technology to solve these problems. We just need the will to do it. The current system is broken, and we need to fix it. Not with patches and band-aids, but with a fundamental redesign that puts users first. It's going to be hard, but it's worth it.

---

Next in the series: How blockchain technology is modifying what is possible in the market?